masthead-background-img

A Guide to CMMI™ Maturity Levels

Capability Maturity Model Integration (CMMI) is a set of globally recognized best practices designed to help businesses improve key processes and optimize performance. An organization implementing processes the meet the intent and value off the CMMI practices can aim to achieve a Maturity Level (ML) rating demonstrating it takes quality and process improvement seriously. According to the most recent CMMI Technical Report: Performance Results, organizations that adopt CMMI see real process improvement results across various areas of their business, with quality and productivity topping the list.

Knowing the proven efficacy of CMMI, stakeholders can have confidence in partnering with businesses with a CMMI ML rating. Often, a CMMI Maturity Level rating is contractually required. For example, some government contractors may be required to have an ML rating of 2 or higher to bid on contracts, particularly those dealing with security, IT, systems or software engineering.

Regardless, any organization interested in improving its processes, quality, and performance can benefit from CMMI and achieving an ML rating. This guide describes the different CMMI Maturity Levels and how to work toward achieving each one.

Overview of the CMMI Level Framework

CMMI guides businesses through its model using different levels. The level framework in CMMI follows an evolutionary path, providing structured guidance to reaching objectives. 

For example, the practices within CMMI Practice Areas are grouped and organized by different levels. Each Practice Group (PG) level builds upon the one preceding it, increasing an organization’s capability within a particular Practice Area. 

During a benchmark appraisal, businesses must demonstrate capability in PG levels within core Practice Areas, as well as in domain-specific Practice Areas. 

CMMI appraisers consider an organization’s ability to satisfy PG levels to rate its capability and maturity levels. An appraiser also considers whether an organization’s processes are habitual and persistent, among other factors, to determine an ML rating. Once an appraiser assigns a maturity level rating following a benchmark appraisal, they’ll send their results to ISACA for approval.

The 5 Maturity Levels of CMMI

CMMI has five Maturity Levels, each building on the one below it. Every level can help an organization understand its current capabilities and determine what is needed to attain a higher maturity.

259822472

CMMI Level 1

Maturity level 1 represents the starting point of CMMI adoption. At this level, organizations commonly lack standard processes and take a reactive approach to challenges. Although work may get completed, it’s often done beyond timelines or over budget.

As organizations progress through this initial stage, they identify and address performance issues. They may invest in training or establish basic metrics to measure performance.

To achieve an ML 1 rating, an organization must demonstrate capability for practices grouped in the first level of each core Practice Area and each applicable domain-specific Practice Area.

For example, as an organization focuses on satisfying the PG Level 1 requirement within the core Practice Area, Causal Analysis and Resolution (CAR), it might investigate the cause of an unexpected project outcome. Additionally, team members may determine what changes they need to make to prevent a similar outcome in the future. An appraiser will consider if the organization met the intent of PG Level 1 within the CAR Practice Area as they assess its maturity level.

CMMI Level 2

ML 2 demonstrates that an organization consistently plans projects and monitors progress toward performance objectives, incorporating lessons learned in ML 1. However, businesses rated at ML 2 generally do not yet prioritize data quality or understand how to use data to drive process improvements on an organization-wide level.

Achieving ML 2 requires satisfying PG Levels 1 and 2 for all core Practice Areas in addition to relevant domain-specific practices. Demonstrating capability at this maturity level may entail developing standard processes or collecting data to analyze an issue at a higher level.

CMMI Level 3

ML 3 is the most commonly achieved rating. Nearly 80% of appraisals were performed for ML 3 from 2019 to 2023.

Once an organization reaches ML 3, it’s equipped to achieve performance objectives on both a project level and an organizational level. Companies that have progressed to ML 3 embrace a proactive approach to challenges and improvements and recognize that their processes are company assets. They emphasize using data to measure performance and facilitate growth. 

Organizations must satisfy PG Levels 2 and 3 in all core PAs, plus targeted Practice Areas, to obtain an ML 3 rating. Depending on the organization’s goals and needs, achieving ML 3 may require deeper analyses of business objectives and current performance data or monitoring risks related to project activities.

Although an ML 3 rating illustrates a greater investment in process improvements and organizational standardization, it’s not without challenges. Organizations may face resistance from teams as processes become standardized. To maintain an ML 3 rating or progress to the next level, businesses should focus on fostering a culture of continuous improvement.

CMMI Level 4

Achieving an ML 4 rating is a significant milestone because it demonstrates that an organization manages its processes using statistical and other quantitative techniques to understand and refine them. In general, high-maturity organizations recognize that data is necessary to accurately identify issues, measure progress, efficiently make decisions, and ultimately achieve customer-aligned objectives.

To obtain an ML 4 rating, businesses must prove capability in PG levels 1 through 4 in all core and targeted Practice Areas. An example is that an organization might need to demonstrate that it can analyze root causes using statistical data.

Overall, organizations rated at ML 4 are prepared to handle challenges effectively. However, they may face obstacles in finding employees trained to analyze statistical data. They may also struggle to ensure data collection methods are accurate. Allocating resources to training, data collection tools, and professional partnerships can help businesses maintain a high ML rating.

CMMI Level 5

ML 5 is known as the “optimizing” level and is the peak of CMMI achievement. Stakeholders can have confidence that organizations rated at ML 5 are stable, flexible, and ready to innovate.

At ML 5, businesses focus on maintaining effective processes while leaving room to embrace innovation and improve procedures as needed. They are equipped to pivot rapidly and can accept new opportunities, driving business growth. ML 5 businesses continue to use statistics and quantitative techniques to optimize processes and performance.

To achieve an ML 5 rating, an organization must satisfy PG levels 1 through 5 in all core Practice Areas as well as domain-specific, targeted Practice Areas.

While ML 5 is the highest level an organization can reach, it’s not the end of CMMI. ML 5 businesses must sustain continual improvement and maintain a framework for reviewing and integrating feedback.

The Benefits of Pursuing CMMI High Maturity

CMMI Maturity Levels 4 and 5 are considered high maturity and that directly correlates to high performance. Achieving a high maturity CMMI rating level comes with many advantages:

  • Improved productivity, efficiency, quality, and performance
  • Greater stakeholder confidence and satisfaction
  • Ability to establish quantitative objectives based on business needs
  • Ability to understand process improvement ROI clearly
  • Ability to understand how variations in processes impact performance
  • Ability to rapidly respond to risks and challenges and make data-driven decisions
  • Improved cost control
  • Reduced rework
  • Decreased employee turnover
  • Greater ability to deliver services or products on time and within budget
  • Enhanced risk management
  • Ability to focus on innovation and outpacing competitors

Why Trust BTI

Business Transformation Institute (BTI) has consulted with organizations on CMMI and other process improvement methodologies since 2005. Our real-world experience in project management, software development, and systems engineering helps us understand both the consultant and organizational perspectives. Some of our team members have written components of CMMI and its training and appraisal method.

Additionally, we’re authorized by ISACA to support organizations as they navigate CMMI at any maturity level, and we have experience performing Benchmark Appraisals for a range of industries. We understand what it takes to achieve a desired maturity rating while aiming for practical, measurable, and sustainable change. 

259822471

Contact BTI for a Benchmark Appraisal

BTI is ready to help your business grow through our CMMI consulting, training, and appraisal services. Regardless of the maturity level you wish to achieve, we’re committed to driving measurable improvements for your organization that align with your goals. Contact our team today to begin the transformation.

Previous ArticleCore KPIs for Software Development  Next ArticleA Guide to CMMC Level 2 Compliance